Walker Scobell has heard the rumors, and he is not worried. At a Percy Jackson and the Olympians panel in New York on Thursday night, the Season 3 star joked that Robert Pattinson is about to take Percy Jackson away from him.
According to the fan account that posted the clip, it started with Tamara Smart, who plays Thalia Grace, joking that by Season 5 the cast would be full of British actors. Scobell ran with it. “Yeah, I’m pretty sure there’s talks of Robert Pattinson playing Percy,” he said. The moderator suggested the two could just trade jobs and Scobell could be Batman instead. Scobell passed: “I don’t know if I could pull that off, to be honest with you.”
GAROTO! Walker quando Tamara brincou que, até a 5ª temporada (🙌) teremos muitos britânicos no cast, Walker disse:
— Portal Walker Scobell Brasil (@PortalWalkerBR) November 19, 2026
“É, eu vi que querem colocar o Robert Pattinson como Percy. Um re-cast.”
apresentador: “vocês podem trocar, e você seria o Batman”
“não acho que consigo sustentar o Batman…”
To be clear, there is no casting news here. It was a running gag on a panel full of cast members having fun the night before their new season premiered. Pattinson is British, which is how Smart’s joke got there in the first place, and he played the Caped Crusader in 2022’s The Batman, which is what made the moderator’s trade offer land.
A Night At 92NY
The panel took place at 92NY on November 19, after a screening of the Season 3 premiere, and was moderated by Josh Horowitz as a live recording of his Happy Sad Confused podcast. Smart and Scobell were joined by members of the cast to talk about the new season.
Season 3 adapts The Titan’s Curse, the third book in Rick Riordan’s series, and it premieres November 20 on Disney+. It is a big season for Smart. Thalia joined the story at the end of Season 2, and in The Titan’s Curse she joins Percy and the gang on a quest, with plenty of friction between the two children of the Big Three along the way. Critics have been kind so far: the season opened with a perfect Rotten Tomatoes score before its premiere.
Why The Joke Works
Scobell was cast as a teenager to match the age of Riordan’s hero, and he has played Percy since the series premiered in December 2023. The show is built around its young cast growing up alongside their characters. Swapping in a 40-year-old movie star would undo the whole premise, and everybody on that stage knew it.
Disney+ has the Season 3 details, and Seasons 1 and 2 are streaming now for anyone who needs to catch up before the premiere.
For all the Disney news without the clickbait make sure to follow our accounts! Facebook | Twitter | Threads | Instagram | TikTok
